Saturday, February 10, 2007

The Country Club at Brookline

I was lucky enough this past Fall to be invited to play The Country Club at Brookline (ranked # 33 in the world). One of the five founding member clubs of the USGA, The Country Club was built in 1895. Brookline is a leafy suburb surrounded on three sides by the City of Boston and the club is built right in the middle of it all. Brookline was described in the 19th century as the richest town in America. The mansions still visible today as you drive around Brookline are a testament to that. John F. Kennedy was born in Brookline. Driving past the course you wouldn't even know The Country Club is there, it is surrounded by fences on all sides. If you manage to see the discrete sign for The Country Club, you drive up the tree lined entry driveway. A couple hundred feet in you are greeted by a guard house manned by the ever present Woody (pictured below). Look closely since Woody is not a person but a wooden dummy, although a well dressed one with a jacket, tie and top hat. He's the golf world's equivalent of a scarecrow and your first sign that maybe the WASPs in this part of the world have a sense of humor after all.

As you continue down the entry road (you are crossing the 15th fairway between Woody and the clubhouse) you come upon one of the most beautiful clubhouses in the golf world, which fits perfectly into the landscape with its beautiful ocher color.


The Country Club has a unique name not because they are pretentious but because they were the first country club in the U.S., and I would have to say that they did it right. It would be difficult to improve on anything they've done here. You approach the clubhouse around an oval driveway. Ahead of you is an old building that is the men's locker room. To your right are several other buildings - one used for curling, another houses the enclosed tennis courts, another for squash, etc. The place is a bee-hive of activity. Although it is only five miles from downtown Boston, when The Country Club was built it truly was a club located in the country with a variety of sporting activities including, originally, horse racing, which is no longer present. A club for all seasons, there is an ice skating pond with an associated club house down near the middle of the course.

CC #9
The view from the 9th fairway

I was lucky enough to play The Country Club on a brilliant day, and it was very enjoyable. The course has the most varied routing I have ever seen. It follows the contours of the land and meanders its way around the property. More than a half dozen times I was surprised when the member or caddy pointed in the opposite direction of where I thought we were going to go to the next tee box. The course was designed by a variety of people; originally by Willie Campbell, with modifications by William Flynn, Geoff Cornish and Rees Jones with no singular influence being exerted. One of the features that you find throughout the course are the glacial rock formations that holes are routed through and around, such as the par five 11th hole, aptly called Himalayas, seen below. You hit your tee shot on this hole from a high, elevated tee to a crevice in the rock canyon on the left side of the fairway. Midway between the bottom of the canyon and the elevated green is a creek that runs through the bottom of the hole. Not the type of hole you see every day and one that really uses the geography present to maximum advantage.

CC #11
Rocks from the last ice age feature prominently on the 11th hole

The terrain for the 18 holes is quite hilly and used to good effect, although it is not a terribly difficult course to walk. I know I am beating a drum on this topic, but I am again struck by how the world's great golf courses contain so many blind shots, which I really like. The #1 handicap hole, the third, seen below, is another case in point with a blind second shot to the green.

CC #3 
Blind second shot on the 3rd hole at The Country Club

CC #3.1

View of the green, hole #3, from the fairway

The course also has a Redan hole, the short 12th, although it is a non-traditional version of the Redan. The hole plays from an elevated tee sharply down hill and is only 130 yards. Although it's not a typical Redan hole, I thought it was very good and guarded by a plethora of bunkers in the front. We had just completed playing the front nine and were walking down the hill back toward the tenth tee. 

The tenth and first tees essentially share the same very large tee box. If a group is teeing off on one tee box, good etiquette calls for you to wait for the other group to hit before you do so and vice versa. As we were coming down the hill there were about 15 young golfers mingling around by the first tee, all wearing khakis and crimson polo shirts. As we approached, I noted that they all looked perfect. Perfectly fit, perfectly groomed, good looking, confident and athletic. It was the Harvard golf team (men's and women's), with monogramed Harvard golf bags, who use The Country Club as their golf course. It really made me think how privileged they were. Let's see, you look like Richard Gere or Jennifer Aniston, you go to (arguably) the best college in the world, are athletic, smart and play on the golf team. Is it possible to have a brighter future? These kids have got life by the balls. If anyone has ever told you that life was fair, they were lying.

I had a good caddy at The Country Club, although I had a tough time understanding him with his heavy Boston accent. After my drive on the first hole I had "143 yaawds" to the green and somehow managed a "great paah" after missing the green.

The 17th hole at The Country Club is one of the most historic in the game. It is where Francis Ouimet won the playoff against Harry Vardon and Ted Ray in 1913 to pull off one of the biggest upsets in golf history by winning the U.S. Open at age 20 as an amateur, against two of the world's best. It is also the famous green where Justin Leonard made his monster putt during the 1999 Ryder Cup and then the Americans had the unseemly, but justified, celebration on the green. I would say that the green looks a lot different than it does on TV. The green is long and narrow and is two-tiered. The putt Leonard made is even more impressive to me now, having seen how much break there is, given the two tiers.

The greens at The Country Club are all small. Along with Inverness and Pebble Beach, among the smallest in championship golf. Another unique feature of the course are the small chocolate-drop style mounds that are present around some of the greens. They force you to play from an uneven lie as a penalty for a missed green.

Like other turn-of-the-century clubs, The Country Club jealously guards the traditions of the game, thankfully. The Country Club is an old-school place to play. Like at Oakmont, you need a medical exemption to take a cart. They believe, rightly, that you should walk if you can. This policy also has the positive impact of allowing them to continue to support the noble profession of caddying.
Truth be told, Boston is not one of my favorite cities. I have always found it a bit uptight and stuffy. I was pleasantly surprised by my experience in Brookline. The club is family oriented, welcoming and not pretentious. Sitting in the dining room is a treat since the place drips with history. Most of the women sitting having lunch the day I was there were modeled after Julia Child: big-boned, elegant and proper. I also noted more than a fair share of men wearing bow ties at the club. No doubt, they still have a number of Boston Brahmins around with names like Saltonstall, Cabot, Peabody and Putnam!

The idyllic setting at The Country Club

The Country Club at Brookline actually has 27 holes, the 18 hole course that the members play every day and also a nine hole "Primrose" course. Championships are held on a composite course which includes a handful of holes from the Primrose course mixed in with most of the holes from the 18 hole course. I played the members 18 hole course and not the composite course.

If you get a chance to play, I recommend wandering around the buildings around the oval driveway before or after your round. They are all old and impressive. It must be a New England thing not to modernize, and like Fenway Park, we should be greatful for that. The locker room is untouched from when it was built with old historic lockers and pipes hanging from the ceilings. There is an old glass-doored telephone box from the turn of the century in the locker room. The curling pavillion is a wonderful old musty place done in "Green Monster" green. The Country Club is proudly guarding its provenance and is one of the most historic and special places in the world of golf.

"To me, the property around here is hallowed. The grass grows greener, the trees bloom better, there is even warmth in the rocks. And I don't know...but somehow or other the sun seems to shine brighter on The Country Club than on any other place that I have ever seen" -- Francis Ouimet


Anonymous said...

what about the chowder in the clubhouse?

MacBoube said...

I just played TCC for the second time (as I played it in the 1980's) and I have to say, the course was absolutely magnificent. The Clyde and the Squirrel make up a very stout 18 holes. The condition was top deck, almost as good as any course can be. It sports firm, true, fast, and small greens. The fairways are exceptional, with turf that creates the most perfect lies, as they feel very fluffy - not tight, making ball striking that much easier. Their rough is very consistent and challenging at 3 to 4" high. Maintenance is certainly as good as it gets at TCC, as I rank it amongst the ten best maintained courses I have ever seen. It really has a tremendous men’s locker room, reeking of history around every corner. It is a wonderful place for dudes to hang out and drink and socialize. The clubhouse is in a separate building and is even more historic. I think the most amazing thing about TCC is all the different things they do, as I will attempt to list them. (Forgive me if I leave something out). Golf (27 holes), tennis, paddle or platform tennis, swimming, skeet shooting, curling, and on their own pond they have figure skating, ice hockey, and fishing. The member who hosted me said they use to have hunting on the grounds, too. Back to the golf, the course is just splendid, with tough and interesting par fours that dominate you during the round. 17 and 18 are amongst the best two back to back par four finishing holes in the world. Their history is incredible, and playing them is downright glorious. It makes you feel very special indeed finishing on those two holes.

Anonymous said...

This is great info to know.

逆円助 said...


Anonymous said...

Played it last Saturday. Everything you said is 100% correct. Amazing place.

Unknown said...

It is to be noted that the house of Francis Ouimet still stands just across Clyde St at #246; I'm amazed that the writer failed to mention it.

Anonymous said...

this course is amazing. i had the chance to not only play the "main" course but also the composite "open" course (incorporating holes from all three nine hole courses on the grounds). a pity the rankings don't reflect the course all championships are played on?

thomas said...

You talk about being privileged (the Harvard students). I have not had the privilege to play TCC despite living in Brookline for many years. I do play regularly on the adjecent golf club, the former club of Francis Quimet, Putterham Country Club. When playing this course you get all the good stories about what goes on behind the gates of TCC. Despite not having played the course or know any of the members of TCC, I have great appreciation for the community work TCC management does for the town of Brookline. TCC organizes tournaments for the local teachers, fire fighters and police officer, and allows the local high school varsity team year to use the practice grounds and course in their quest of becoming the next Francis.

I can respect the members desire of privacy and exclusive rights to preserve something as fine and delicate, but at the same time still gives back to the community in which the club is situated. This is truly a great club and I hope one day, I get to play it.

Anonymous said...

this golf course is the biggest waste of time i have ever spent at a private club! I did not play the "composite" they use for tourneys, but in a word.....BOOOORRRIINNGGGG!

Anonymous said...

A very good write-up. I entirely agree with your comments about blind shots. I like to think early golf course architects designed their courses like artillery officers choosing defensive positions: High ground with a reverse cambers being the most difficult to hit. It is worth noting that perfect drives on 3rd,4th,6th do not leave blind shots, but the target for your drive is small. For instance on #3, for a view of the green, you've only got a 10x30 yard strip of fairway. Legend has it that Hogan hit this precise spot in each of his rounds in the 1963 US Open (despite high winds).

Ghost of Seth Raynor said...

Good write up, I have played TCC at least 50 times and you nailed it. 27 spectacular holes...they added 500 yards to the Champ course in preparation for the 2013 US Am and a beastly course is now stouter with the additional yardage.

My only complaint is that there was not mention of having a Fernando post round. A Fernando is as much a part of the experience as the course.

Anonymous said...

I am playing it tomorrow. I have been online for about half an hour looking for a scorecard and all I can find is a picture of a squirrel. I guess I should expect that when googling "The Country Club". Either way, I have lived in Boston my whole life and this will be my first time out there. I've played all over the world and a beautiful fall day in Boston at TCC has all the makings of perfection. If you hear someone screaming FOUR! between 12:15 and 4pm, you'll understand why I signed this, Anonymous.

Ellen Brewster said...

My mother spent most of her life at The Country Club. When she passed away, the family gathered from all over the country at The Club for a dinner overlooking the greens after the funeral. Most of us adult cousins piled into her old Ford station wagon (frugal old New Englanders didn't fuss with fancy autos) for the trip to this dinner. Hilariously, we chugged along the drive up to the clubhouse in what was now a smoking and spitting jalopy.

As we rounded the oval, ironically the car died right in front of the portico at the front door. So appropriate that it was here her trusty Ford gave up the ghost, having brought her that very spot so many times over the years. Rules were that no cars were to remain there over night but once the power-that-be realized it was Katharine Peabody Brewster's vehicle, The Club graciously allowed it to remain until AAA came to haul it away the following morning.