Sunday, August 01, 2010

Colonial Country Club

Colonial Country Club (ranked #100) is located in Ft. Worth, Texas. It is the only top 100 course ranked in the state. Readers located outside the U.S. may not be familiar with the psyche in The Lone Star State, which is summed up cleanly in their unofficial state motto, "Don't mess with Texas." Texas isn't so much a separate state as it is a state of mind. Ft. Worth has an interesting history as a genuine Western city. If someone walks around Dallas with a big cowboy hat they would be assumed to be a Yankee trying to fit in. In Ft. Worth, the cowboys are real, based on the local cattle industry. Ft. Worth is also a major rail hub, but more about that later. Ft. Worth's city motto is "The West Starts Here," and there is much truth to that. It was previously nicknamed "The Paris of the Plains" due to its freewheeling reputation during the mid 1800's. Ft. Worth had a rowdy saloon district in the latter part of the 19th century, known for its debauchery and crime. It was called "Hell's Half Acre," predating the use of this nickname for the seventh hole at Pine Valley by a good fifty years.

Colonial was built by John Bredemus in 1936, and modifications were made by Perry Maxwell a few years later. Maxwell was the same designer as Prairie Dunes & Southern Hills. The course is famous because it was Ben Hogan's home course during the height of his career.

The Golf Course

Colonial starts out simply enough on flat ground. The first hole is a straight forward dogleg right par five of 555 yards, one of only two on the course. As you can see in the picture below of the first green, the course is well bunkered around the greens. It has possibly the whitest sand I have seen on a golf course. Stepping into the immaculate bunkers can be blinding because they are so white.

1st green
The first green

It becomes clear pretty quickly at Colonial that the greens are small. Along with Pebble Beach, Harbour Town and Inverness, they are among the smallest of all the courses I have played.

The three hole stretch three through five is known as the "Horrible Horseshoe." Horseshoe, because the third tee is right next to and left of the fifth green, and the three holes swing around in a U shape. Horrible, because they are not easy. The third is a 468 yard par four dogleg left with a slightly elevated green. The fourth is a tricky 220 yard par three, also with an elevated green.

4th green
The par three fourth green

The fifth hole is one of the most renowned in the world. It gets endless accolades. Golf's 100 Toughest Holes includes it on its list. The 500 World's Greatest Golf Holes ranks the fifth among its top 100. Dan Jenkins, in his 1966 book The Best 18 Golf Holes in America, selected the fifth hole as well. It is a 459 yard par four (481 for the pros), dogleg right. As Jenkins describes it: "The drive must be almost perfect, a slight fade and 250 yards out, if you are going to reach it in two. But fade too much, and there is the Trinity waiting. You can bail out to the left but there is a line of trees and a ditch there." The Trinity he is referring to is the Trinity River, which snakes along the outside of the course.

It's a hard hole for sure, but not that hard. As my readers know, I'm not exactly a scratch golfer and I parred the fifth. In fairness, the prevailing left to right wind wasn't blowing when we played; I imagine it's a different hole if the wind is up.

The sixth is a lovely 381 yard par four, dogleg right with another elevated green. For the record, the greens were as well conditioned as I've seen in my travels, so my compliments to the greenskeeping staff. They keep this place immaculate, which, given the heat and humidity down here, they should be commended for.

6th green
The elevated sixth green from the left side

I must say, though, that walking off the seventh green, I was not terribly impressed with the course. Very pleasant, for sure, but I was thinking to myself, ok, so it's in the top 100 in the world because Ben Hogan was a member. Nothing wrong with that. We should respect the wee ice mon. I'm good with that.

By the time I walked off the eighteenth green, I had a different opinion.

I liked the 169 yard par three eighth hole. It has some wicked bunkers and trees around it, and the green slopes back to front. Starting on this part of the course, there are two dramatic changes. First, there is a lot more change in elevation and terrain; and second, you play alongside the massive adjacent railroad yard. I know, stick to the golf, you fool, who cares about rail yards? Well, in my view it is an integral part of playing at Colonial. I'm not talking about an occasional train that goes by like at Carnoustie or Royal Lytham & St. Annes. We're talking a major working rail yard right next to the course. Serious rolling stock, my friends.

8th hole
The par three eighth hole

Because of the cattle business and stock yards, Ft. Worth has had railroad yards since 1876, so they have been here a lot longer than the golf course. It's not unusual to be hitting a drive or a putt and hear train cars smacking into each other as they are coupled up. Train whistles toot their horns throughout the round more than Donald Trump when he is on camera.

The tenth was also one of my favorite holes. It is a nice 381 yard dogleg right par four. Your second shot is over a big swale to a well protected green. Like Harbour Town, Colonial is a narrow, shot makers course. You don't need to bomb the ball to score well here. What you need to do is hit around trees and be smart with club selection.

10th with swale
The tenth hole, approach to the green

The eleventh hole is the other par five on the course, and it is Texas-sized at 600 yards from the pro tees. The green is protected extremely well as seen below.

11th green
The par five eleventh green

It won't be uncommon to hear high-pitched screeching as you play around this part of the course as metal train wheels brush against the metal tracks as they are continually put together and leave the station. I'm not bringing up the trains to be critical of them. In fact, the course has a perimeter of trees that block out most of the noise. It's not obnoxious, but it is constant background din all day. Just like it would be hard to describe Moray Golf Club in Scotland without talking about the everpresent jets taking off from RAF Lossiemouth, it's hard to talk about Colonial without discussing the bustling rail yard.

The twelfth was also a very good hole, a 400 yard par four dogleg right with a bowl-like fairway. The elevated green is protected by trees and beautiful bunkers. The green is the smallest on the course, which is saying something here, given that they are all small. Where Colonial excels is in its subtle but sneaky-hard use of doglegs. Ben Hogan's assessment of the course describes how the doglegs are used so effectively, "A straight ball will get you in more trouble at Colonial than any course I know."

12th green
The tiny twelfth green

Fifteen was my favorite hole, another 400 yard par four, this one another dogleg right. Tee shots will kick right-to-left off the sloping terrain. There is a creek that guards the left side of the elevated green, which you approach from the bottom of a hollow.

15th green
The fifteenth green

Sixteen through eighteen are strong finishing holes that I enjoyed. It is a finishing sequence like this that makes Colonial such a good venue for the PGA tour. Seventeen is a 373 yard par four that gets progressively narrower as you approach the green, and you have to hit over a swale in the middle of the fairway. The eighteenth has water left of the green. When Phil Mickelson won the tournament here in 2008, he hit a miracle shot over trees after being completely out of position. When he made the putt for birdie, some drunken fool did a cannonball into the little pond adjacent to the green. He was arrested, but you must agree that it was a rather imaginative move. At least he had the decency not to take his shirt off before he jumped in. The video on YouTube.

Obviously, I liked the back nine better than the front and liked Colonial overall. I almost always walk when I play, but I took a cart at Colonial because, like Shadow Creek, it's just too hot. We were treated with true Texas hospitality by everyone at Colonial including our forecaddy who was a nice young man who always had a mouth full of chewin' tobacca' and called us "y'all" the whole round.

As they say, don't mess with Texas.

Colonial and the rail yard from the air


Anonymous said...

The irony...the guys from puregolf have played about half the number of courses you have in just over 6 months in the name of charity without any networking or schmoozing.
I have a suggestion as to how you might get a game on Augusta: contact Warren Buffet (a member) and tell him that you will give away 99% of your wealth if he gets you on.
The down side is of course that you will have to give away 99% of what you own but provided it goes to a good cause that shouldn't be a problem, right?
After all, Warren is doing it so it can't be that hard can it?

Anonymous said...

You mentioned that you are tired of all the 7400 yard courses. What's the best short course you have played?

I would like to try to design a 6300 yard course that would be challenging even for a pro to break par. Sometimes pros will hit it 310 yards but way right and still have a shot to the green.
Why should they give a big advantage for the powerful to win in golf? Even tennis is favoring bigger,more powerful players now.
Of course,longer players would still be able to use a 7 when I am using a 5,but you could design it were length isn't as much of an advantage.

Top 100 Golfer said...

Best short courses played are Cruden Bay, North Berwick, Prestwick and Camargo.

Anonymous said...

Does Merion rate as a short course?

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the advice on Cruden Bay. It looks like an ideal course. I am trying to plan a trip next year and based on your blog and a few other internet sites I want to play Royal County Down and Cruden Bay for sure. And the 3rd course might be Royal Dornoch or Royal Porthcawl.Do you have a suggestion for the 3rd based on me playing the 1st two? I know Royal Portrush in in NI also. I know someone I can stay with in Bristol, so that is why I am thinking of Royal Porthcawl.

I am also thinking about renting clubs, since they cost about $50 to rent per round and I think it costs 50 each way to put them on the plane. They might even charge extra from the NI to Scotland.

Is a handicap card really needed, since I don't have one yet? I plan on getting one by next year,but I am just wondering if they really check. I shot in the low 80's as a teenager in the 1980's,but haven't played in 20 years and am just starting up again.

It looks like many of the courses, RCC for sure, don't have a range. Is there a range near RCC that you used?

Anonymous said...

I forgot to ask. Is it easier or more difficult to get on courses like RCC or Cruden as a single player? I am trying to get a partner to go with me,but who knows if I can find one.

Brian said...

I noticed you still haven't played Cascades...find a way to play that ASAP. It is a Flynn masterpiece and probably the best mountain golf course ever constructed.

Jack said...

Have never played Colonial but have been to the tournament several times. It is rich in tradition and a golf must see. The compactness of the course makes it a spector's heaven.
Attended 77-82 and this past year. New technology has changed the course dramatically. Back in the day #11 was reached in two by only a few,now everyone but Pavin seems to be hitting it. I remember pros hitting 3 and 4 irons to #8,this past year it was 8 irons!
Colonial should have been taken out of top 100 the year Clearwater destroyed it but it remains only because of its rich history,much like Fireston.

Anonymous said...

"Colonial should have been taken out of top 100 the year Clearwater destroyed it but it remains only because of its rich history,much like Fireston."

But does the top 100 have to be the toughest 100? I think there could be 300 courses near each other at the top. People have different tastes.

I am still using clubs from the early 80's--Hogan Apex II irons. Do you really get that much more distance from the current irons if they are both hit flush? I have a newer metal driver,but it doesn't seem I get that much extra distance than a persimmon.

Paul from Granbury said...

Was a member of Colonial for 25 years and never got tired of playing it. Great walking course, and we finally got pull carts approved.
The membership was split down the middle on the pull carts, but now they seem to like them. The white sand has just happened the last 2-3 years. Drains better and more consistent.
Enjoyed your review.